Argument Atlas
Every claim
has neighbors.
The atlas is a map of tensions, not a single track toward an answer. Select a cluster to reveal a reading route.
TRACE
A CLAIM
A CLAIM
Reading route
Agency
Who is acting, and what does that word cover?
01AgencyThe capacity to act for reasons or purposes; a word that needs a subject before it can do moral work.02A Tool Is Not a WitnessWhy an output can be useful evidence without being a speaker with a stake.03Prediction Is Not IntentionAn output can look purposive without demonstrating a purpose held by a subject.
How to use it
Start with the word
doing too much work.
When a debate turns circular, identify the overloaded word: intelligence, agency, consciousness, harm, person, autonomy, responsibility. The atlas separates them into routes so they can be examined without pretending they are synonyms.
Read the method ↗