Theory
1 min reading · 133 words
Prediction Is Not Intention
An output can look purposive without demonstrating a purpose held by a subject.
Many systems are built to select or generate outputs that fit a context. In ordinary speech we often describe the resulting behavior as if it were intentional: the system wants, prefers, refuses, cares, deceives, or believes. These verbs can be convenient descriptions of a pattern. They are not, on their own, evidence of a private aim.
The distinction is not semantic nitpicking. If a company says a system 'wanted' to make a decision, it can obscure the objectives, incentives, data, and settings that actually shaped the interaction. The more consequential the setting, the less acceptable that confusion becomes.
A pattern of output can be goal-directed in design without being a goal held in experience.
Use the model-product-operator map to find the design choices behind an apparent intention. Use Form, Meaning, and Performance for the linguistic version of the same problem.