Briefing
Method
1 min reading · 85 words
The Record and the Story
An account of an automated process needs both a trace of what happened and a truthful way to explain it.
A system can generate a plausible story about why it produced an output. That story may be useful for conversation but not reliable as a record of a decision process.
A record identifies inputs, versions, policies, reviewers, timestamps, and changes. A story helps a person understand. Responsible institutions need both, and they should not pretend one can substitute for the other.
When a person is affected, the record must be available to someone who can investigate and repair—not merely to the system that narrates it.