Governance
1 min reading · 90 words
Law Is Not Metaphysics
A legal status distributes powers and duties; it does not reveal the inner nature of its holder.
Law uses categories for practical reasons: to make contracts, allocate liability, protect rights, establish procedures, and create standing. Those categories are immensely consequential. They are not laboratory instruments for detecting experience.
This matters when legal personhood is used as a rhetorical stand-in for consciousness or when a company's legal responsibilities are treated as evidence about a product's mind. Both moves confuse institutional design with ontology.
The important question is concrete: what power, duty, remedy, or liability would a legal change create, and who would exercise it? Moral Patienthood Is Not Legal Personhood gives the fuller map.